Recent History

History had been her worst subject in school, but only because she didn’t care for facts or committing them so rigidly to memory. Still, Alice fancied herself a sort of historian, working in the ladies’ exchange. She had always loved things from another time. Vintage, antique—the exact distance from the present didn’t matter. If she had to trace it back, it was her grandmother’s house that had first possessed her: Pepto-Bismol pink bathroom, chessboard linoleum, wallpaper of roses repeating forever. Radio humming out golden oldies. Her grandmother herself in her checkered house-dresses, still styling her hair from a clipping taped to the mirror: Country Club Coif. It was like going back in time whenever Alice visited, inside of her grandmother’s careful conservation of an era. The era’s careful conservation of her grandmother. Whenever people said that someone was a product of their time, Alice wondered: well, who wasn’t? Did anyone ever transcend the time during which they were most alive? Like a role in a period piece that took your entire life to get just right. Even if time was moving on somewhere else, everyone was already busy mastering the lines they had first been assigned. Alice didn’t think her grandmother dated, just that she was dutifully dedicated to her break-out role.
Alice loved the past because she loved fashion, and the past was always in style. She had been voted best dressed in her high school yearbook, due to her innate sense of how to make eras mingle like guests at a party, their voices far enough away to be unsure who said what. But she and the past were star-crossed lovers, suspended where she was in time’s web—a hopelessly contemporary creature. To her, the past wasn’t exactly a renewable resource; rather, she believed there was already enough of it to last a lifetime, if not forever. She never thought about the future.
The ladies’ exchange was called Déjà Vu. Alice had started working there when she was sixteen and never left. Now she ran the store, managing it for the owner, a woman named Priscilla her grandmother’s age—or rather, the age her grandmother would had been if she were still alive. Déjà Vu took clothes and hats and shoes and jewelry on consignment from women across the city, things the women didn’t want anymore and were by nature some sort of old. The store sold a few other items too: books and lamps and assorted knickknacks. Alice had furnished the Victorian house she rented with some of those knickknacks, as well as objects from the sets of the Art Deco theater downtown, her second-favorite place in the city besides Déjà Vu. The theater mostly put on pieces by traveling playwrights and then sold the sets for cheap when they moved on. Through the theater, Alice had acquired an Edwardian living room, a mid-century kitchen, a flower-child bedroom, a Roaring Twenties powder room. She walked through history whenever she was at home, and then emerged in the sunlight of a new day, blaring the songs of summers lost as she drove to work to deal in the past. In this way she made time a blur, without even asking the world to spin backwards on its axis. She lived through generations in a day.
Alice loved Déjà Vu—its smell of musk and mothballs, the light leaking from the cracked windows, the dressing room curtain that blew up coquettishly in the breeze when she left the back door open for air, like Marilyn Monroe’s dress in The Seven Year Itch. Behind the counter, the Victrola radio ventured from Elvis to Aerosmith in the span of an hour. She watched old movies on the classics channel from a tiny TV hung on the wall. All those beautiful starlets whose skin glowed in black-and-white as if perpetually moonlit—it seemed unreal that most of them, if not all, were dead now. To her, they were alive and forever young as long as the movies were playing, their souls inside the screen, a séance she kept ongoing inside the store.
Alice spent her days breathing in old fads. She missed the years they belonged to the way one misses old friends—or so Alice imagined. All of her own friends had drifted over the years, and it was only after months, sometimes years, of lapsed contact that she thought to remember them, and by then it seemed like they had slipped too far away, like boats out to sea, disappeared from view. But the clothes she surrounded herself with were like dutiful pen pals from places she had never been. She looked at bell-bottoms and shearling coats and longed for the 70s; she saw flapper dresses and cloche hats and mourned the 20s—she couldn’t have missed them more if she had been there herself.
The city she lived in was already dead by the time she was alive. Long ago once stately and grand, it was now hollow and decaying. It was like living in someone else’s memory; it was like living in a haunted house but finding out it was you and everyone you knew that was haunting it. She could have left and moved somewhere else: a larger, more glamorous city, like she always dreamed of, one with a still-beating heart. But it was hard to leave the place you haunted. And inside Déjà Vu, she already was somewhere else.
Alice lost track of time whenever she was at the shop. Time didn’t pass in the past. She opened the doors in the morning and let the day in, and then somehow it was night again. The same way she had come in that first morning and then somehow it was years later. How many years? She had to stop and think, stop and count. She still considered herself a hot young thing. Wasn’t she? The past lapped at her feet like waves, but never swept her completely out to sea.
But then came a day when a woman came in with things Alice recognized from her life’s own trajectory—low-rise jeans and varsity jackets, capris and culottes. Things she remembered her peers wearing to picture days and movie dates and basement hangouts; things she’d even worn herself before she developed her mishmash bricolage style, before she had become herself.
“I’m sorry,” she told the woman. “We’re interested in pieces a little more vintage.”
The woman blinked. “These are at least twenty years old. Isn’t that the very definition of vintage?” she said.
Alice paused. “By definition, yes,” she said. “But.” She paused again. The truth was, she just could not picture these things among the rest of the items in the store; they were like rocks among gems. She wondered how they would all get along, like cliques in the school cafeteria.
“But what?” said the woman. “I thought you took retro items.” But those pieces she had didn’t seem past enough to be past. They were just junk, just jetsam, excess weight that time threw overboard in its relentless march forward.
There was another girl in the shop that Alice hadn’t noticed coming in. She was flipping through one of the racks in the back, dressed in an all-black shapeless shift. “I would buy those,” said the girl from across the room, gesturing toward the clothes the woman was trying to pedal to Alice. She looked almost as if she were floating inside her amorphous garment. “They’re exactly the look. The look I’ve been looking for,” said the girl.
Alice considered. Priscilla had always wanted her to keep up with the trends. Trusted her to stay with the times. She didn’t want to fall behind—could she be falling behind? Letting the past pass her by?
She told the woman she would take the things.
After the exchange was completed, the girl came over to the counter. “I’ll buy those off you right now,” the girl said. She rifled through her purse, its small size belying its seemingly bottomless depths. She flipped through a stack of cards, and one fell to the floor. As the girl bent to retrieve it, Alice saw it was an ID from the local high school, the girl’s graduation year emblazoned on a sticker across it. Alice did the math: the girl had been born the year Alice had graduated.
“Are these all you have like this?” the girl asked. Alice read the name on the credit card: Hattie Wright. It seemed an old-fashioned first name for someone so young—then again, sometimes people said that about Alice’s own name. But she had always thought it classic, rather than dated. That enough time had passed for it to feel new again, to be freed from associations of the old, to belong to a different generation of people. Maybe the girl, like Alice, appreciated the splendor of the past, its particular sheen. In any case, the girl seemed much older than she was, with her own line of credit and ageless gaze, unwavering as a sphinx. She peered out from tiny sunglasses with what looked like a hint of suspicion, as if Alice was keeping something from her.
“For now,” Alice said.
“Well,” said Hattie, “I would totally buy whatever else you get like these. If anything else comes in.”
“Keep checking back,” said Alice. “I never know what we’ll get.”
And more things did come in, more and more things from a period of time Alice didn’t consider worth remembering, despite the fact that she actually could—unlike the rest of the shop’s items, who belonged to epochs Alice had spent her life only imagining. The new items evoked the same feelings as fluorescent lighting and overplayed pop songs—they made Alice nauseous, made her feel like being stuck in the backseat on a long car ride to somewhere she never wanted to go.
But to Hattie, they were treasures. She was insatiable; she came into Déjà Vu every day, buying up every new piece. Even still, she always asked Alice, “Anything else?” In the weeks that passed, the question grew increasingly urgent, bordering on desperate. “Anything else?” Hattie begged, her eyes pleading behind her sunglasses. Hattie had already bled the store dry of the things she was looking for—the women of the city couldn’t get rid of their past fast enough to meet Hattie’s demands. It was like she subsisted on it; it was a type of nectar to her, or blood.
Alice considered. Despite her work, she had never personally parted with anything she had ever worn. She kept all her clothes from her own past packed away in her attic. She would never wear them again, but that wasn’t the point. Keeping her old things made Alice remember that she too had a history. Sometimes she woke up and felt unanchored from herself, like she had no past or future of her own, just a tenuous sense of a present. Her beloved grandmother was long gone. Her parents had always felt more like strangers, and now they essentially were, both of them scattered to retirement homes on opposite coasts. But her clothes had held her and housed her and then she had shed them like a skin. She once heard that each cell in the human body regenerates every seven years; that you are, materially speaking, a completely different person in different eras of your life. Later she questioned the veracity of this fact. But she had already absorbed the idea, digested it as truth. She thought of her clothes as past versions of herself, and as such they deserved a burial, the boxes in her attic a type of mausoleum. She never considered there might be a market for their exhumation, despite the fact that this was the very nature of her occupation. 
The truth was, she had been hard up for a long time; the truth was, she lived beyond her means. Her rent was more than she could really sustain, but she could never leave her Victorian, with its leaky gabled roof and parquet floors and endless rooms to fill with items from the past. Living in that house, with all its original features and charm intact, was the closest she could get to embodying the dream state she ran away to in her mind, where everything was soft and distant, hazy and romantic. And, as she always reminded herself, she could never afford a home like that elsewhere, in a real city. There was her 70s Oldsmobile convertible, with its constant, ravenous demand for repairs but undeniable glamor, the beguiling purr of its motor when it was finally happy. The summer trips abroad that she had put on her credit card—all worth it to be in faraway places that seemed more impervious to the effects of time.
She had her debts. She could use the money. She didn’t have to sell everything.
When she got home that night, Alice plucked some of the most obvious offenders from the boxes in the attic. The biggest blights against the defined aesthetics of her adulthood, the most once-ubiquitous. She started with just a few items—a hoodie emblazoned with the slogan of the manufacturer, a lacy tank top—and brought them to Déjà Vu the next day.
Hattie admired Alice’s cast-offs like artifacts from a lost civilization, grasping the cheap synthetic fabrics gingerly, carefully. “These are actually from my own collection,” Alice admitted. “Wow,” Hattie breathed, as if the things were delicate or precious or of actual value.
“What was it like wearing them?” Hattie asked Alice. It felt good to be asked about herself, to answer simple but expansive questions. So much of her day, her life, went by without really talking to anyone at all.
Alice thought about her own history. She told Hattie about the house she grew up in: a boxy gray Colonial identical to all the other boxy gray Colonials that surrounded it, both inside and out—barely any trees separating one from the next, their indistinguishability bleeding into each other on neatly spaced lots where grass never seemed to grow. All the houses had sprouted up at once, a few years before Alice was born, a burst of new hope that was never watered right and instead wilted around her and everyone she knew.
Alice told Hattie about her parents—their faces the same tired gray of the home they all lived in together, without ever feeling like it was something shared. Their days wasted away at desks, biding their time until they could be back in the gray house in front of the TV. The TV—all those bad sitcoms playing one after another, ad nauseam, their gaudy colors the brightest in their home. The sitcoms’ flimsy representations of reality, their canned laughter wafting through their otherwise silent house. She remembered when she first learned that the laugh tracks weren’t live, were just recordings of distant voices from some other time. Like how they say that the light you see from stars already burned out a long time ago—that what you see shining in the night sky is only a memory.
Over the following weeks, then months, Alice slowly cleared out the boxes in her attic—the pastel flip-flops, polo shirts, and peasant tops, track suits and tube tops and trucker hats—bringing more and more of her own past into Déjà Vu for Hattie to suck up. Over each exchange, she would tell Hattie more about the era the clothes came from. Hattie would always listen intently, spellbound, like the most quotidian crevices of Alice’s life were something riveting. She wanted to know every detail—nothing was too small or mundane, not the layout of Alice’s house or her morning routine. Alice told her about the metallic sound of the pop CDs she collected, where every track sounded the same, voices shrouded in filters and effects to disguise the fact that they originated from a living breathing human. She told her about dances to that same bad pop music in the sweaty cafeteria of her middle school, with its dingy low-hanging ceiling, where transcendence from that life seemed impossible. The way she had to dial up the internet, those staticky noises of connection that sounded like they were coming from space. The diet shakes, the diet snacks, the diet pills: life all about being less than you were. Eyebrows ripped and ripped into tiny lines until they were barely there at all. Wasting away Saturday afternoons at the mall with its dank echoing corridors, seeing more and more storefronts abruptly vacated, walking under lights that made her look sickly, eerie, like a ghost of herself.
The present had felt the way those lights at the mall did—too harsh, illuminating all the wrong things. All Alice could remember wanting was to get out from under its glare. She told Hattie about first seeing the ad for Déjà Vu in the paper—the retro-style lettering, the drawing of a beautiful woman, dressed in a housecoat just like her grandmother’s. EVERYTHING IS BETTER IN THE PAST, it said.
Déjà Vu was in a part of town she had never been to before, never had a reason to. But one day after school, she took two city buses to visit. She remembered how she felt when she finally reached her destination: standing outside in the cold winter air, encased in her ugly puffy coat like a sleeping bag, staring at the displays in the lighted windows. The elegant, nearly otherworldly clothes on the mannequins. Stepping inside to the warm glow of antique lamps, the crisp crackle of a vinyl record playing. That rosy smell of the past covering everything like potpourri. She remembered trying on an embroidered dress and silk coat, the finest garments she’d ever put on her body. They had their own special names—a tea dress, a brocade coat—as the kind woman who ran the shop told her, who introduced herself as Priscilla. Alice remembered standing in front of the dressing room mirror with lightbulbs strung around the edges, just like the kind movie stars used. In that mirror, she became radiant instead of drained and ghostly. She finally saw her reflection as something she wanted to belong to her.

Alice lost track of how long exactly her routine of exchanges with Hattie had gone on. Sometimes it felt like she could not remember a time before; time had begun to feel even more liquid than usual lately, between digging through her own past to rehash it to Hattie and living in the regular nostalgia of her home and the shop. But then again, she had stopped checking off days on a calendar years ago.
One day, Hattie told Alice that she was going to be in a play the following week, at the Art Deco theater. She dug through her bottomless bag and retrieved a flyer. A ticket was paper-clipped to the top. “If you want to come!” Hattie said.
Recent History, the flyer read—One Night Only at The Reliquary Theater, with next Saturday’s date at the bottom. Neither the flyer nor the ticket offered any further information.
“I’m actually the star,” Hattie told Alice. “Star, and director.”
“Wow,” Alice said. It seemed quite an accomplishment for someone so young. But Hattie was so precocious, so self-possessed; leaking the essence of talent, even if Alice had never seen her do anything that required it.
As Hattie left the store that day, it suddenly occurred to Alice that she had never seen her actually wear any of the clothes she seemed to want so badly; Alice had only ever seen her in the same shapeless black shift, each and every time she came in.
The night of the play, Alice closed up shop. She swung on her brocade coat, the very one she had first tried on in the store all those years ago, at the beginning of everything. She always wore it when she went to see plays at the theater—Priscilla had told her that the theater was what coats like that had been made for. “This coat has past lives inside its stitches,” Priscilla had said, her voice as dreamy and distant as if she was speaking of an old love. These words had comforted Alice at various points, reminding her that the garments she wore on her body contained more lives than she could ever live, even if she tried—enough lives so that her own never had to feel empty.
The theater, like the rest of what surrounded it, was deteriorating. Even so, it was still beautiful, with its flickering neon marquee and dusty gold chandeliers, its halls of clouded mirrors. Its soaring ceilings were covered in murals of the heavens, ceilings that rose up and up and up, seemingly forever—the opposite of Alice’s middle school cafeteria. Inside the theater, ascension towards something greater seemed possible, even imminent.  
Alice’s favorite place to sit was the very back row of the balcony, where she felt like she could disappear most completely into the world of whatever was on stage. The night of Hattie’s play, she settled into one of the red velvet seats. The smell of mold was maybe more pronounced than usual, she noticed. But, she reasoned, it was all just part of the ambience, the enchantment of the past. She looked around. She was alone in the balcony, and from her seat, it was hard to tell, exactly, how full the rest of the theater was. She could spot a head here and there but the theater seemed quieter than usual, as it waited for the play to begin.
When the curtain finally went up, Alice saw Hattie standing alone in the middle of the stage under a spotlight, still and solemn, the same way she held herself in the shop. She was wearing low-rise jeans and a polo shirt. She was inside a reconstruction of a home that felt strangely familiar in its gray characterlessness. Alice watched as Hattie sat on a couch just like Alice’s own childhood couch: black pleather, overstuffed. She watched her turn on a TV just like Alice’s own childhood TV: boxy and silver. Sitcom sounds filled the theater, followed by the sounds of a laugh track. The theater’s audience—suddenly sounding much fuller than it had appeared—laughed in turn, their living voices blending with the dead, canned ones so there was no way of telling which was which, where one began and the other ended. Watching the stage felt like being inside a bad dream, but Alice’s eyes were wide open: everything so familiar, and yet something so essentially wrong, a feeling of unease rising from some deep part of her.
The curtain went down and then up again, a different set revealed: a girl’s bedroom, saccharine pink. Lava lamps bubbling and beads hanging from a doorway to nowhere. Plastic stars stuck to a false ceiling, casting everything beneath them in a grossly green hue. In the center of the stage, Hattie sat in front of a boxy old computer with a jewel-toned back. Staticky space noises filled the theater—those sounds of waiting to connect. Hattie waited and waited. When the curtain went down, she was still waiting.
Curtain down and up again, a new set: Hattie carrying shopping bags, wearing clogs and a velour tracksuit. She was surrounded by mannequins behind glass windows, adorned in matching ensembles, everything illuminated under glaring, fluorescent lights. Hollow-sounding pop music echoed from a distance that felt as far and faded as a memory. Hattie walked to an empty frame of a mirror at the edge of the stage, a red ruched dress hung on top of it. Hattie took the dress, pressed it to her body, and looked deep into the place where her reflection should be, but instead was just a window to the audience. Hattie’s gaze stretched to some indistinct place, searching for something it did not seem she would ever find, until she met Alice’s eyes in the balcony. Then Hattie’s gaze morphed from wistful longing into that beseeching, insatiable gaze Alice knew so well at this point: Anything else? her eyes asked. Alice gaped back at her, the two of them locked into a private staring contest, as if the two of them were alone in the theater.
But just as quickly as it landed, Hattie’s gaze shifted from Alice to some unknown region beyond her, as if right through her, like she wasn’t there at all, toward somewhere beyond the limits of the theater’s walls. The shift was so swift, so smooth, that Alice wondered if she had imagined their momentary secret meeting.
Murmurs of admiration rippled through the audience. It struck Alice how resplendent Hattie looked in the center of the stage, not at all ghostly or washed out under the fluorescent lights. She was beaming, almost divine. Like a true star.
The curtain sank once more—according to the program, there would be a brief ten-minute intermission. The house music swelled in tune with Alice’s anger. Hattie had stolen her stories, her clothes—her life! She had plagiarized her personal history! It was the purest kind of identity theft.
Alice wondered what to do. She glanced at her watch; its soft brown leather and ornate timepiece had lived a full life before it had ever known her wrist. She had nine minutes left in intermission. She stole down the balcony stairs, snuck down the sides of the theater. Into the empty lobby, void of others. Through a door with a sign that read “TO BACKSTAGE—AFFILIATES OF THE PRODUCTION ONLY BEYOND THIS POINT.” Well, she was an affiliate of the production if she was anything. Besides, there was no one to stop her—no one there at all.
She entered a long hallway, completely dark aside from the shred of light leaking out from underneath a door at its end. Alice walked towards this light, let it guide her. As she grew closer, she could make out a sign: STAR’S DRESSING ROOM, it said. Alice rattled the door, expecting it to be locked, but to her surprise, it opened easily. Hattie sat alone in front of a lighted mirror, just like the one in the Déjà Vu dressing room. She appeared completely unfazed by Alice’s presence. “Hi, Alice,” she said, as if she had been waiting for her arrival. “I’m glad you could make it.” She did not turn around, seeming to speak more to Alice’s reflection in the mirror than to Alice herself, as if they were two separate entities. 
“You stole my past,” Alice began. She glanced at her own reflection as she spoke these words, saw herself standing on the edge of the room as Hattie dominated the frame.
“I didn’t think you wanted it,” Hattie responded, shrugging. She was dusting her body with glitter, brushing metallic shadow onto her eyelids.
Alice considered this—well, she didn’t really, or didn’t think she did, but that didn’t mean someone else could just take it. Did it? Hattie hadn’t lived through any of it. How could she think she could just perform it?
“But it’s mine, not yours,” she said. It was hers to keep locked away, secure in her attic and her mind, to revisit only if and when she chose. It was not meant to have a life of its own, to be revived.
“Well, it’s not like you were doing anything with it,” Hattie said as she lifted herself from her chair. “It’s time to go back on,” she said, motioning for Alice to come with her.  
Alice followed her out of the dressing room, into the wings of the stage. She considered leaping out in front of the audience, telling them that her private life had been poached. That what they were witnessing were her personal memories, and she hadn’t authorized their reproduction. They weren’t intended for public view. But as the curtain started to rise once more, Hattie walked forward, pushing Alice back—but softly, gently. “Just watch,” she said. “Watch from here.”
The applause sounded again. The sound was enormous—so much louder than Alice thought was possible. She could not see any bodies creating the thunderous noise; everything was obscured by the stage lights. Trying to look out into the audience felt like staring into the sun. Like she might permanently obliterate her vision, forever imprinting this image onto her retinas. All she could do was watch Hattie, and the show she was making out of Alice’s life.
How beautiful it suddenly looked—her past—from under the stage lights, from her place in the wings. Now that it no longer belonged to only her, and would no longer fit neatly inside, even if she could somehow get it back.



Nikki Barnhart’s work has been published in The Cincinnati Review, Post Road, The Offing, The Rumpus, and elsewhere, and been nominated for Best of the Net, Best Small Fictions, the AWP Intro Journals Prize, and the Pushcart Prize. Originally from New England, she earned her MFA in Fiction from The Ohio State University and is currently a PhD student in the University of Cincinnati’s Writing and Literature program.

Next
Next

Raspberries, Blackberries, Strawberries, and Blueberries