A Conversation
with Nikki Barnhart

Gina Nutt: What were your earliest inspirational seeds for writing “Recent History”?
Nikki Barnhart: I distinctly remember the story came to me while reading Dana Spiotta’s novel, Innocents and Others—thematically, the two are very different, but there was something about the voice of that novel that energized me and drove me to the page; I really do believe that absorbing others’ work can have a lot of power on your own creative process.
The beginning of the story tumbled out easily, in that strangely magical way they sometimes do. I wrote some of it on the balcony of my apartment at the time, and I remember coming up with the line about making eras mingle like guests at a party from the voices of my neighbors drifting up to me, faces unseen.
I’ve been obsessed with the idea of nostalgia ever since I was a kid, which is kind of funny now, but my feelings were always so intense. Even though I had relatively very little life experience to even be nostalgic about, I was always missing the past—the previous summer, the previous school year—and worrying the future would never be as fun. Back then, I thought of nostalgia only as a personal feeling, rather than a broader cultural one, but of course they play into each other. Here I think I was interested in examining that personal vs. cultural divide. I was also thinking about the idea of “the anxious interval” (the recent past, too close to be considered cool or interesting, more uncomfortable than anything: “a place, a style, a set of references we avoid, repress, sublimate, have selective amnesia about, stow away, throw out, deliberately forget”) vs. “the goldmine” (“a cultural era the present is currently reviving”), terms coined by the musician Momus in a LiveJournal post. I was thinking about the bizarre experience of my generation’s own ‘anxious interval’—the mid-2000s—becoming the new goldmine.

GN: I love how the accumulation of details lends itself to the experience of moving through a vintage store. The sentences here also swept me up in the story. What considerations are on your mind when juggling narrative drive and style? What is your sentence work like on the levels of image and sound?
NB: Thank you! Voice and style are the craft elements I’m most interested in as a writer; getting the voice right is the entry-point into all of my stories, and is essential to any momentum I make on a project. I almost always write in first-person, but Alice’s voice instantly came to me in third: distant, lyrical, longing, a little old-fashioned (but maybe not as much as she thinks). For me, the sound and feel of a story’s voice will often come before I fully flesh out character and narrative, so I kind of work backwards from there. I read an interview with Garth Greenwell where he says “a successful style gives the sense of an entire life condensed to a voice” and that’s become north star advice for me; I think coming to really understand that entire life within the voice—what is and isn’t necessarily revealed, but still contained—is the key to unlocking a story’s narrative drive.

GN: The connection Alice and Hattie share shifts throughout the story. Each woman navigates her romanticized version of nostalgia against reality, which culminates when they lock gazes during Hattie’s play. Do you consider these characters more similar or opposite? Are they kindred vintage-loving souls or do you see Hattie as a foil to Alice? How did you approach drawing out this connection?
NB: I read—or maybe listened to, I can’t remember—an interview with Miranda July about her novel The First Bad Man, and how she wanted to explore a story in which the relationship between two characters transforms, and then transforms again. The unspoken part here is that a relationship has to be defined first before it can transform into something else: there needs to be an equilibrium established before it’s disrupted. But I was interested in a relationship that isn’t ever neatly defined. On one hand, you could see Hattie and Alice’s relationship as one that transforms and transforms again, but I don’t think it’s really changing shape, just rotating to a different angle of the same shape, if that makes any sense.
More directly to the question, I think Hattie and Alice are more kindred souls if anything, but Alice can’t quite see that. As I wrote above, I usually write in first-person because I’m interested in the subjectivity of the narrator but here I really wanted to play with that same subjectivity in third.

GN: Hattie’s play also highlights an intriguing tension between performance and authenticity. I’m curious what role you think memory plays in this dynamic?
NB: I think memory itself exists somewhere in between performance and authenticity. Something I feel is related: Agnes Martin wrote that, “Experiences recalled are generally more satisfying and enlightening than the original experience.” I’m fascinated by this idea, both as a lens to view her art and on its own terms. I think it’s an interesting way to think about the role of performance in memory: an experience recalled is at least partially constructed and can be replayed endlessly, if one wishes, rather than experienced once. Of course a memory is more satisfying because an experience finally bends to our will, and belongs to us alone—or at least, until someone else remembers things differently. I also can’t help thinking about that line from Lost Highway: “I like to remember things my own way. How I remember them…not necessarily the way they happened…”

GN: What’s in your creative mosaic? Books, music, restaurants, films, visual art, fashion, ephemera, architecture, anything that energizes your writing.
NB: I love this question—talking and hearing about influences is my favorite thing. There’s so many things that inspire my writing but here’s just a few:

The works of David Lynch—I’ve been conducting my annual fall rewatch of Twin Peaks; I don’t think any other piece of film/television has ever, or will ever, give me as intense a feeling as the last scene in The Return does.

Nancy Rexroth’s IOWA photographs, which I’ve been working on an essay about. (They also, to my mind, perfectly capture the mood of Beth Nugent’s brilliant and under-read collection, City of Boys, also an influence.)

The music of Fog Lake and Grouper: the soundtrack to my November, my birthday month.

And always: the short stories of Joy Williams and Miranda July.